I did end up getting my spoiler wrapped in gloss black PPF...it came out perfect and i'm very happy with the look and result, I definitely prefer it over the CF since everything else on my car is gloss black (but for those with any other CF aero bits the CF is also really, really nice looking, can't really go wrong either way...just a matter of everyone's personal OCD).
And just in case anyone is in the same situation, I had this installed on top of PPF (my whole car is PPF'd + ceramic), the shop simply buffed + thoroughly cleaned the areas where the spoiler attaches to, said they've done it many times for far more expensive cars and they've not had any problems. No issues in over 300 miles of driving with this spoiler already, she ain't going anywhere lol.
View attachment 86346View attachment 86347View attachment 86348