New video "WARNING: The Lotus Emira Market Just Flipped — This Could Cost You"



“Flipped” feels a bit click-baitish to me. The data actually shows the current average price around ~$92.5K, essentially in line with the original US MSRP of ~$93.9K, which is quite solid, in my opinion. What really changed is that the new MSRP has gone up significantly. As most of us know (and hear over and over), most cars are depreciating assets. The Emira is a niche market, and I don’t expect prices to drop dramatically—similar to what we’ve seen with the most recent Evoras. That said, I wouldn’t buy new today; a gently used example makes more sense to avoid the ~$110K MSRP (or ~$120–125K out-the-door) haircut.

Personally, I don’t like losing money, and I pre-ordered the Emira knowing there was uncertainty about the future market price. That said, I don’t really care much about some depreciation—I’m fine with it and in a position where I don’t lose sleep over it. I bought the car to drive it, as cliché as that sounds. About 99% of cars lose value anyway. There are a few exceptions that appreciate right out of the door, likely less that 0.0...1% ? of the cars (some Porsche GTS models or limited Ferraris), but those typically appreciate only after you’ve already lost (a lot of) money buying other cars from dealers to “play the game,” so it’s usually a poor financial decision overall. Some older cars may appreciate after 15–20 years, but compared to other assets (e.g., stocks), cars are still terrible investments once opportunity cost is considered.

Long term, I think the Emira’s value will remain solid—especially given the drivetrain and the fact that there are very few modern cars left with this kind of old-school charm. The Cayman GTS comes close, but it’s less special and, frankly, much more boring to look at.

Dealer here in Houston is giving $11k off new 2025’s
 
That video is useless clickbait. My first edition is almost 1.5 yrs old and a little over 6k on the odometer --- worth every penny. New costs almost 10k more than what I paid from everywhere I look --- but honestly don't care, drive it and enjoy.....that's all that really matters when it comes to cars IMO.
 
That video is useless clickbait. My first edition is almost 1.5 yrs old and a little over 6k on the odometer --- worth every penny. New costs almost 10k more than what I paid from everywhere I look --- but honestly don't care, drive it and enjoy.....that's all that really matters when it comes to cars IMO.
Agree.
The concensus is all cars depreciate. Enjoy what you own.
At what point does a good performance car bargain become an incredible performance car bargain? Make one yours. Supplies are limited.
 
Happy to add that I got an offer of +10% than what I paid for it new (from a real buyer). I'm not selling just sharing. If you keep the Emira in mint condition, it may hold its value actually.
 
A house, a car, a piece of art or anything else you might have only has a value/price at the moment in time when you are selling and you find someone to give you an amount of money. At any other point in time, an item is “worth” what ever you might wish it to be.

Simples.
 
I’ve hardly seen any depreciation in used UK market in the past year. There are 1 or 2 outliers but values seem to be holding well enough. That’s based on Autotrader advertised price.
 
The increase in MSRP will bring Emira buyers to the used market, which depending on the offer, will fluctuate the value.

The new MSRP Emira is just being delivered in NA dealer, it is still too soon to say that the public is aware of the new price increase, so we still have to give them time before jumping into conclusion.

My hypothesis is that people will buy used, the used market will thus have a lower inventory (which means less freedom on specs) and what will be observed is a higher "plateau" and less depreciation for used Emira than originally expected.... (of course no Emira will increase in price, just less depreciation).

The question is will people buy the new MSRP price if they don't find their specs in the used market or will they go for another sport car? Unfortunately I think it will be the latter...

My last question is what will happen when Gen Z and late Gen Y (Which are notorious auto transmission enjoyer) get enough money to buy sport car... will they go for manual or auto? Would it be enough to affect the transmission market? I think so.
 
Last edited:
I thought the emira demand would benefit from no more ICE caymans but that’s been scrapped. No matter.

I look forward to a future YouTuber who discovers the emira, lol.

“Did you know they built a mid-engined car with a supercharged v6, manual shifter, light weight where the driver is truly in control? AND it looks like a baby Ferrari? Say hello to the Lotus Emira…” (in a British accent of course)
 
“Did you know they built a mid-engined car with a supercharged v6, manual shifter, light weight where the driver is truly in control? AND it looks like a baby Ferrari? Say hello to the Lotus Emira…” (in a British accent of course)
I've always wondered why the Emira hasn't sold in larger numbers. Ask a petrol head for a wish list for their perfect sports cars and the result won't be far off describing an Emira.

Yet same petrol head presented with an Emira goes and buys a Tesla..
 
Well according to the registration bill I just got CA is valuing my Emira at $100,769.20.
 
I've always wondered why the Emira hasn't sold in larger numbers. Ask a petrol head for a wish list for their perfect sports cars and the result won't be far off describing an Emira.

Yet same petrol head presented with an Emira goes and buys a Tesla..
Price of a new Emira keeps several buyers out, especially with the current economic uncertainty.
Here in the US, more drivers can afford a Tesla, not an Emira.
 
Dealer here in Houston is giving $11k off new 2025’s
That brings them to what?

The price growth from 24 launch msrp to 26 is big time, well beyond typical price growth.

It’s a lot easier to be unbothered about these things if your cost basis is the MSRP from launch…

Prior lotus have held value extremely well. Better than lambo/mclaren/aston/etc. about as well as standard production non-hybrid Ferrari models.

All things considered it’s pretty impressive.

That said, I’m not sure whether prior models had the sort of YoY msrp growth for identical car (ie same generation). That may be a point of divergence vs historical residuals data
 
Last edited:
I've always wondered why the Emira hasn't sold in larger numbers. Ask a petrol head for a wish list for their perfect sports cars and the result won't be far off describing an Emira.

Yet same petrol head presented with an Emira goes and buys a Tesla..
And if a manual transmission isn't important, potential Emira drivers may be turning to the Corvette
 
I've always wondered why the Emira hasn't sold in larger numbers. Ask a petrol head for a wish list for their perfect sports cars and the result won't be far off describing an Emira.

Yet same petrol head presented with an Emira goes and buys a Tesla..
I hate to say this, but the car is dramatically underpowered, and it’s too cheap.

525hp, $150k, I think they’d sell more.

It’s expensive enough to be out of reach for Miata types, but not expensive enough to be a “flex”

That’s really tough demo wise
 
Identical trajectory of the Elise, Exige and Evora, and each held their ground later in years. It’s a car. As KitKat said drive the car and the value will drop. Betting this is no different than most other cars people have in their garage. To me value drop is a ridiculous concern unless you buy a car to flip or trade it in every two years (in which case you’re always stacking depreciation costs).
The only real problem I see is that due to the price increase, aka $110k+ its going to drop big in the first year.

Would you pay $116k for a loaded 2026, or $90k for a slightly used 2024 with usually less than 7000 miles.

But beyond the first year depreciation, they should flatten out pretty fast. All really depends on what Lotus does in terms of future Emira's. Aka, if they actually deliver a hot version with more power, better seats...etc... then the first years could drop a lot. Specially if later years get a way better engine.

Assuming Lotus actually has enough cash to get one off the ground.
 
I hate to say this, but the car is dramatically underpowered, and it’s too cheap.

525hp, $150k, I think they’d sell more.

It’s expensive enough to be out of reach for Miata types, but not expensive enough to be a “flex”

That’s really tough demo wise

I was in LA / Malibu recently and saw 60+ Porsches of every variety.

I saw exactly one Lotus; a yellow Emira with a white circle on the door. I gave him a thumbs up. I saw more SF90s and F8s.


The Emira's design and relative exclusivity to other sports cars means it flexes harder than any new 150k car.

But the demo in question is probably turned off by the lesser name recognition and marketing reach, the smaller dealer network and/or the overt focus on driving engagement.
 
I hate to say this, but the car is dramatically underpowered, and it’s too cheap.

525hp, $150k, I think they’d sell more.

It’s expensive enough to be out of reach for Miata types, but not expensive enough to be a “flex”

That’s really tough demo wise
What Tesla has 525hp and costs $150k?

Model 3 Performance has that power level, same for Model Y Performance. Neither are $150k. Even a 1021hp MS Plaid is not $150k new.

that said, I wouldn't buy a Tesla new, I didn't. I bought my 2021 MS Plaid in 2023 with 40k on the clock for $60k. And about a year after that, they were 50k'ish. 1021hp AWD 9 Second Saturn V rocket for sub $60k is ALOT of straight line speed for the money.

It also happens to be a great daily driver. It accelerates like a Saturn V, but also turns and stops like one (aka, not at all). But it is supremely comfy, easy to drive, and actually extremely cheap to own. Plug it in, thats about it. I've spent $112 in electric over the past 12 months and driven about 8000 miles. I work from home, so don't drive much anymore, but I am 70 miles from family, so every trip to see family is about 140 miles.

I know for a fact I've already spent more than that in gas on the Emira as I track it in Fuelly. I've driven the Emira 4323 miles, at an average of 21.3mpg, and spent $827.43 in gas.

Now, granted, I tend to drive the Emira quit 'spiritedly', so I'm not getting the best fuel economy, but it wouldn't come down by much.

I can tell you that every one of the 4323 miles I've driven the Emira has more smiles than the Plaid. Though the plaid does have the ability to induce sheer terror when the foot goes to the floor. People scream, some people even cry when it's over. Definitely amusing on my end.
 
Likewise, I'm planning to keep this car until I kick the bucket, so I'm not too worried about anything said in the video. 26K smiles, and counting.
To reiterate earlier posts, this car is destined to become a classic. (For some inexplicable reason, I’ve generally proven right on crystal ball classics since the time I was in high school). That it happens during my lifetime mattereth not.
 

Create an account or login to comment

Join now to leave a comment enjoy browsing the site ad-free!

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top