It really comes down to what you want from a car, but personally, I would never swap an Emira for an M2.
I’ve driven several of the new G87 M2s and there’s no doubt it’s a seriously capable machine. The S58 is a monster of an engine, the chassis is incredibly composed, and the traction/DSC system is one of the most effective setups you’ll find on a rear-wheel-drive car today. From a performance and numbers standpoint, the M2 absolutely delivers.
But the driving experience is a completely different story.
Like you said, the Emira feels special even at 30 mph. The steering feedback, the seating position, the chassis balance — it has that “exotic” character that you simply don’t get from a BMW, no matter how fast it is. The M2 is quick, competent and brutally effective, but at the end of the day it still feels like a “car.” The Emira feels like a sports car in the purest sense, with a sense of occasion every time you climb in.
And looks-wise, it’s the same contrast. The M2 with carbon packs is aggressive and purposeful, but the Emira has the proportions, stance and overall presence of something far more exotic. Park them side by side and it’s immediately obvious which one turns heads for the right reasons.
The only thing that really tempts me toward the M2 is the engine and the sheer effectiveness of the drivetrain. But if what you enjoy is feel, feedback and that sense of uniqueness, the Emira is on another level.
So for me, it’s not even a question, it depends on what you value, but I wouldn’t trade the Emira for an M2.